Non-Fiberglass vs. Fiberglass Insulation

Insulation is one of the most important materials in any home—but rarely the most discussed. It lives behind the walls, out of sight, which makes it easy to overlook. And in most cases, standard fiberglass insulation ends up being the default.

It’s affordable. It’s everywhere. Every big-box store stocks it in rolls and batts. But what most people don’t realize is that standard fiberglass insulation may contain formaldehyde, and installing it can release tiny glass fibers into the air—both of which pose health concerns for installers and residents alike.

So… are alternative insulation materials worth it? Let’s take a look.

 

❌ NOT THAT: Standard Fiberglass Insulation

Standard fiberglass insulation has been used for decades. It’s cheap and familiar—but it comes with some baggage.

What’s the issue?

  • Often made with formaldehyde-based binders, which can off-gas into the home

  • Can irritate skin, eyes, and lungs during installation

  • Breaks down over time, especially if exposed to moisture

  • Not always made from recycled content

  • Still reliant on high-energy manufacturing processes

It gets the job done, but it’s not the cleanest, healthiest, or most forward-thinking choice.

 

✅ USE THIS: Alternative, Non-Toxic Insulation

There’s a growing list of high-performing, non-toxic, and often more sustainable insulation materials—many of which outperform fiberglass in comfort, durability, and indoor air quality.

A few to consider:

  • Cellulose – Made from recycled newspaper; high R-value and fire-retardant

  • Sheep’s wool – Naturally moisture-resistant, mold-resistant, and formaldehyde-free

  • Recycled denim – Non-itchy, safe to install, made from post-consumer jeans

  • Cork or hemp batts – Renewable, breathable, and great acoustic properties

  • Mineral wool (rock wool) – Fire-resistant, mold-resistant, and formaldehyde-free

 

💰 Are Alternatives Cheaper?

In many cases, alternative insulation costs slightly more up front, but the long-term benefits are easy to justify:

  • Healthier indoor air quality

  • Safer for installers and contractors

  • Improved durability and moisture resistance

  • Higher recycled content and environmental performance

  • Helps meet green building certifications (LEED, WELL, Passive House)

And when insulation lasts longer, performs better, and protects indoor health, it’s an investment—not an expense.

 

🛠 Justifying the Upgrade

If you’re making decisions as a landlord, investor, or home renovator, here’s how you can justify alternative insulation:

  • It reduces liability and improves air quality for tenants or owners

  • It supports your sustainability goals and brand story

  • It appeals to conscious buyers and renters looking for healthier homes

  • It aligns with long-term performance goals—especially in energy-efficient or airtight builds

  • It reflects thoughtful construction, even in invisible places

🌱 It’s What’s Inside That Counts

Insulation isn’t sexy. But it matters—a lot. It affects comfort, air quality, energy bills, and even resale value.

So if you're remodeling a home, flipping a property, or building something better from the ground up:

Skip the itchy pink stuff. Choose smarter, cleaner, longer-lasting insulation.

Thoughtfully remaking homes for people and the planet,
Jake

Previous
Previous

Lead Paint and VOCs: Which is Worse?

Next
Next

Mini-Splits vs. Gas Furnaces or Baseboard Electric Heat